We Are Not Alone! All around the world, countries are denying us the right to have identification that reflects our true gender. In Hong Kong, transgender people are also fighting to have their gender identity recognized on official documents.
The South China Morning Post write,
Hong Kong transgender activist mounts new legal challenge over ID card rules
Henry Edward Tse seeks to challenge allegedly unlawful requirements for transgender residents using their preferred sex on ID cardsBy Brian Wong28 Apr 2025A Hong Kong activist behind a court battle for transgender rights has initiated a fresh legal challenge over being required to observe an array of allegedly unlawful requirements to continue using his preferred sex on identification documents.
In a written judicial review application seen by the Post on Monday, Henry Edward Tse’s lawyers argued that the Immigration Department’s new regulations regarding the alteration of identity cards’ category for sex remained legally flawed despite a landmark ruling that called for a policy change.
Tse’s lawyers also called for a statutory scheme to ensure the recognition of transgender individuals, arguing that the government’s failure to allow for the legal recognition of his acquired gender violated his rights to privacy and equality.
Does all this sound familiar? This mirrors what we’re facing here in the U.S.—a constant cycle of legal challenges, especially under leaders like Trump. In Indiana, a new law has just restricted our ability to change gender markers on IDs.
The top court found that the commissioner of registration, a role filled by the director of immigration, had violated the two transgender men’s privacy rights under the Basic Law and the Hong Kong Bill of Rights.
But the top appeal court’s five presiding judges stressed that the change of status on the identity card would not affect the legal status of the cardholder’s sex at birth.
Tse, who founded NGO Transgender Equality Hong Kong, only received a new identity card more than a year later, after the Court of First Instance allowed him to mount a second legal challenge over the delay.
The activist’s lawyers on Thursday filed a third judicial review application to the lower court, highlighting what they saw as the unconstitutional conditions tailored for transgender people who had not gone through the entire reassignment procedure.
This mirrors the trials and tribulations we are going through here with Trump with one court battle after another. In Indiana they just pasted a new law about changing our IDs.
Indiana Daily StudentBy Adelyn Rabbitt
Apr 27, 2025A transgender student at IU was able to get the name and gender on her official identifying documents changed this month. The student initiated her process before a recent executive order in Indiana halted new requests for gender marker changes on birth records, taking that opportunity away from others.
The student, who wished to remain anonymous for privacy and safety concerns, started the process of getting her name and gender marker changed nine months ago, but financial issues delayed her. When she was able to resume the process, she felt the need to complete it quickly, fearing Indiana could pass legislation further blocking her and others from changing their records.[...]Though courts can still order gender marker changes, the Indiana Department of Health has stopped processing and approving such court-ordered requests for changes made after March 4. Requests filed before the executive order and applications in process on March 4 will not follow the new policy but will be reviewed by the Indiana attorney general’s office before approval.
That was one ramification of the executive order signed by Indiana Gov. Mike Braun last month, aiming to align Indiana law with “the biological binary of man and woman.”
We are seeing this kind of treatment toward trans people around the world—especially in authoritarian countries like Russia, China, Hungary, and Guatemala, as well as in nations with strict religious laws such as Saudi Arabia and Iran. These restrictions, whether legal or bureaucratic, have devastating impacts on our safety, dignity, and freedom.